diff --git a/inc/page.php b/inc/page.php
index 8adfa3a..28d1b2d 100644
--- a/inc/page.php
+++ b/inc/page.php
@@ -183,13 +183,16 @@ class Page {
         if ($name_under) {
             $name_under = $this->settings->avatar_names_below;
         }
+        $avatar_source = $this->settings->avatar_source;
+
         if (strlen($uuid) === 36 && $uuid[14] === '3') {
+            $avatar_source = $this->settings->avatar_source_offline_mode;
             // Avatars cannot be associated with offline mode UUIDs (version 3)
             if (!$this->settings->avatar_allow_offline_mode_uuids) {
                 $uuid = $name;
             }
         }
-        $src = str_replace('$NAME', $name, str_replace('$UUID', $uuid, $this->settings->avatar_source));
+        $src = str_replace('$NAME', $name, str_replace('$UUID', $uuid, $avatar_source));
         if (in_array($name, $this->settings->console_aliases) || $name === $this->settings->console_name) {
             $src = $this->settings->console_image;
             $name = $this->settings->console_name;
diff --git a/inc/settings.php b/inc/settings.php
index 9d0dcdc..e45ccfb 100644
--- a/inc/settings.php
+++ b/inc/settings.php
@@ -55,6 +55,7 @@ final class Settings {
          * 'https://minotar.net/avatar/$NAME/25'
          */
         $this->avatar_source = 'https://crafatar.com/avatars/$UUID?size=25';
+        $this->avatar_source_offline_mode = 'https://minotar.net/avatar/$NAME/25';
 
         // If enabled, names will be shown below avatars instead of being shown next to them.
         $this->avatar_names_below = true;