diff --git a/inc/page.php b/inc/page.php
index b9fbf8b..b4939fa 100644
--- a/inc/page.php
+++ b/inc/page.php
@@ -210,10 +210,6 @@ class Page {
 
         if (strlen($uuid) === 36 && $uuid[14] === '3') {
             $avatar_source = $this->settings->avatar_source_offline_mode;
-            // Avatars cannot be associated with offline mode UUIDs (version 3)
-            if (!$this->settings->avatar_allow_offline_mode_uuids) {
-                $uuid = $name;
-            }
         }
 
         $uuid = $this->uuid_undashify($uuid);
diff --git a/inc/settings.php b/inc/settings.php
index 64f5455..9abebd9 100644
--- a/inc/settings.php
+++ b/inc/settings.php
@@ -80,9 +80,6 @@ final class Settings {
         // If enabled, names will be shown below avatars instead of being shown next to them.
         $this->avatar_names_below = true;
 
-        // If enabled, offline-mode UUIDs will be requested from avatar_source instead of player names.
-        $this->avatar_allow_offline_mode_uuids = false;
-
         // If enabled, the total amount of bans, mutes, warnings, and kicks will be shown next to the buttons in the header.
         $this->header_show_totals = true;